HOME    ARTICLES    NEWSLETTERS    FICTION    POETRY    BOOKS   SOFTWARE    LINKS    CONTACT   

Articles

The articles in this section aim to provide writers, particularly new writers, with an insight into the world of fiction writing.

Motivation

Using proverb based themes for story ideas - Part One

Using proverb based themes for story ideas - Part Two

Backup Your Writing for Free Online

Plot: The Fiction Writer's Itinerary

Choosing and Describing a Perfect Setting

Characterisation

Learn to be quiet

Delving into your past

Regaining your writing confidence

Using inclusive language in writing

Copyright: Where To Find Information

Critiquing guidelines

Anti-Virus Tip for Writers

All Rights Remain With the Author: Fact or Fiction?

Critiquing guidelines
By Justin O'Leary

The aim of critiquing is to give "positive" and "helpful" viewpoints. Whenever you're asked to critique another writer's work, keep the following in mind:

Title

Do you think the title is suitable for the story's intended market?

Setting

How does the setting make you feel?
Has the writer covered this aspect adequately? Try to give feedback.

Conflict

What do you think about the conflict(s)?
Try to give feedback.

Characters

Are the characters believable and/or interesting?
Why? Why not?

Dialogue

How does the dialogue sound?
Is it effective?

Narrative

Is there too much or too little or is it just right?

Senses

Does the story explore the senses of smell, taste, touch, sight, sound?

Genre

Is the story in a genre you like or dislike?
This information will give the writer an insight into to your critique.

General

Is the story straightforward?
Is it confusing or long winded in some parts?
In which category would you place the story? e.g., drama, comedy, romance, horror, sci-fi etc.


Tips for giving a critique:

  • When giving your critique, start with a positive general overview before moving on to matters which you feel need improvement.

  • Be nice.

Tips for accepting a critique:

  • Remember nobody asked you to write. It's something you decided to do.

  • Don't take critiques too personally. Be positive - they're free and they'll make you a better writer!

  • If you receive a negative comment, try to remember how you felt about books you've read which didn't meet your expectations. Critiques will help you improve your story.

© Justin O'Leary 1998


ELATED PageKits © 2003 ELATED.com/PageKits.com