Members Bulletin Projects Students Links GuestBook History

SALE POWDER MAGAZINE

circa 1864

FEASIBILITY STUDY

THE RESTORATION, PRESERVATION

and

FUTURE USE OF THE SITE

TABLE OF CONTENTS

MISSION 9;

GOALS

PROJECT PLAN

FEASIBILITY STUDY

BACKGROUND TO THE PROJECT

THE TASK

MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE - SALE POWDER MAGAZINE

HISTORY OF THE SALE POWDER MAGAZINE

ANALYSIS OF THE OPERATING ENVIRONMENT

MAGAZINE STRUCTURE

MAGAZINE SITE

SIGNIFICANCE IN THE BUILT AND SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT

BUILT ENVIRONMENT

SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT

ANALYSIS OF THE PROJECT PLAN VALUES

HERITAGE

TOURISM

EDUCATION

OPTIONS FOR DEVELOPMENT

MAGAZINE USE OPTION 1: HERITAGE BUILDING

MAGAZINE USE OPTION 2: MUSEUM

MAGAZINE USE

OPTION 3: HERITAGE BUILDING, MUSEUM, EDUCATION CENTRE AND PARKLAND

POTENTIAL SOURCES OF FUNDING

PREFERRED OPTION

REFERENCES

 

 

THE SALE POWDER MAGAZINE

a

UNIQUE HERITAGE PROJECT

Mission

To restore the Sale Powder Magazine to its original condition and to develop a viable use for the building and associated grounds that will ensure its economic and long term viability as a heritage asset to the region of Gippsland.

Goals

PROJECT PLAN

The Sale Powder Magazine is unique to Gippsland. It provides a link to the Gippsland goldfields. The restoration of the Magazine and the beautification of the site is based on three values:

  • TOURISM
  • EDUCATION

These values individually or as a combination are considered to be the most relevant in establishing the historic site of the Sale Powder Magazine as a viable and economically sustainable project, that will ensure that the site is preserved as a community asset for future generations.

FEASIBILITY STUDY

BACKGROUND TO THE PROJECT

The Sale Powder Magazine is a building that is unique in Gippsland, as it provides a link from the Sale district to the Gippsland goldfields. The Magazine is the only powder magazine in Gippsland that has survived relatively intact from the gold rushes of the 1860s. Two years ago the Sale Powder Magazine (circa 1864) was ‘rediscovered’. Although the building was in quite good condition it was filled with rubbish and the grounds were unkept and contained many old car bodies.

The Sale Historical Society and the Sale Rotary Club decided to clear the site and restore the Magazine to its original condition so that it could become a community asset. At this stage the site has been cleared and some replanting of native trees has commenced along the bank of Flooding Creek. The restoration of the building has not yet commenced but the Wellington Shire Council, who now own the building, have utilised the services of a heritage architect to produce a schedule of works required to facilitate restoration.

The Magazine was constructed in 1864 to house the black powder used in the mining of gold on the Gippsland goldfields. Sale was the entry point to the goldfields and due to concerns about the safe storage of powder a magazine was built. The Sale Magazine is similar in size to the one at Beechworth except it has some distinct design features not found on any other surviving magazine. Its location on Flooding Creek is unique as it provided the Magazine with its own natural moat to protect it from bushfires.

Throughout the Sale Powder Magazine’s history it was used for its primary purpose until 1881; it was then utilised as an ammunition storage depot for the newly formed militia units of the Victorian Mounted Rifles and the Victorian Rangers who were formed to counteract the Russian threat. Local store keepers then used it to store black powder until the early 1900’s. In 1926 Thomas Kennedy converted the Magazine into a dwelling followed by the Garrett family who occupied it until the Wellington Shire Council purchased it in 1996.

The Magazine has a number of possible future uses which this feasibility study is designed to explore. It documents the various options and recommends the one most viable to ensure that the Magazine is restored and preserved for future generations. The themes that are analysed in this study of the Magazine’s future use are: heritage, tourism and education. Each of these is explored in detail and statistics are given to build a complete picture of viable uses. The priority of the management committee is to restore the building to its original form and landscape the grounds.

The study lists three options for future use and management of the Magazine. Each is more complex than the other and focuses on specific uses and viability for future preservation. Of these, Option Three is highlighted as it offers a more holistic approach to the Magazines future and provides a wider financial base to ensure economic viability.

THE TASK

Since the rediscovery of the Sale Powder Magazine the Sale Historical Society has been instrumental in beginning the restoration and preservation of the building and its surrounds. They successfully lobbied the Wellington Shire to purchase the building and land to ensure that the site would be protected. All the initial clearing of the site has been accomplished with the use of volunteer labour supplied by the Sale Historical Society and the Sale Rotary Club and a number of other community groups. Both of these groups are still heavily involved in the restoration and in seeking funding. The existing support network for the project consists of the major sponsors: Sale Historical Society, Wellington Shire, Sale Rotary Club and Parks Victoria.

After the purchase of the Magazine the management of its restoration, preservation and development was handed over to the Sale Historical Society. A sub-committee was formed within the society to directly manage the project in all facets. The Wellington Shire overseers any management decisions and all major stages of the project must receive their approval. The management structure for the project is outlined below.

Management Structure - Sale Powder Magazine

Wellington Shire Council

Sale Historical Society

President of the Magazine Committee of Management (Mr. Peter Synan)

Magazine Committee of Management


Secretary Treasurer 6 Committee

(Mr. Bruce Anrup) (Mrs. Ann Synan) Members

Proposals for major development work on the site are discussed by the magazine management committee and are then forwarded through the President to the Wellington Shire Council for final approval. Once approved all tasks are directed, organised and executed by members of the committee of management.

People or organisations who are interested in offering assistance can approach any member of the committee on an informal basis or if a formal contact is preferred a letter should be directed to the secretary.

History of the Sale Powder Magazine

  • Built in 1864
  • One of Sale’s oldest buildings
  • Provided a storage facility for black powder

used in the Gippsland goldfields

  • Built on a unique design and location
  • Magazine reflected the transport pattern of

colonial Gippsland

  • Used for military purposes
  • Later used as a dwelling

Until recently very few people knew of the Sale Powder Magazine or of its importance to Gippsland’s heritage. It was rediscovered during a Sale Heritage Study in November 1995 and the building was returned to public ownership, to the newly created super municipality of Wellington in June 1996.

Government powder magazines were built to provide maximum safety for the storage of blasting powder used for pulverising rock on the Victorian goldfields. At first the diggers of the 1850s gold rushes fossicked and panned for alluvial gold. When the surface gold ran out they turned to deep alluvial and quartz deposits. This more complex form of mining required large quantities of powder.

Unprotected stockpiles of powder were the cause of deep concern for public safety, so regulations concerning the importation, carriage and storage of powder were introduced. Anyone bringing large quantities of blasting powder into a district served by a powder magazine was required to keep it there and pay a small storage fee. It was common place for a local policeman to be appointed keeper (Synan, 1995 p 36).

Sale’s Powder Magazine was built in 1864/65 by Irving and Co. (also built Stawell powder magazine), in response to the Gippsland gold rushes of the 1860s. It is similar to the one located at Beechworth, in its size, massive buttressed walls, barrel-vaulted ceiling and slate roof (Synan, 1995, p 36). In comparison to other magazines the one in Sale has some distinctive and unique features. Its brick walls sit on a double course of sandstone blocks, it does not have an outer wall to afford additional protection from the elements like bushfires, as most magazines did and it has four vents located in the ceiling.

The Magazine was built to a military design for black powder and it had a 26 ton capacity. This design was not used after 1888 as gelignite became the preferred explosive. Because of its explosive power it was not economical to build brick buildings so tin sheds with earthen walls were constructed (Synan, 1996). The location provides natural protection as it is surrounded by Flooding Creek on three sides (north, east and south) and by swamp (western side). Due to its location on Flooding Creek, and distance from town, it was sited in an ideal safe position in case of an explosion. It was also not too distant from the local police station charged with its operation.

As with the earlier gold rushes in Victoria, the government sprinkled its Gippsland powder magazines at ports of entry adjacent to the goldfields themselves. Apart from Sale, facilities were provided at the first port of entry, Port Albert, and at Bairnsdale, Woods Point and Omeo (Burill, 1996). The decision to locate a large magazine at Sale reflected the transport pattern of colonial Gippsland. Sale was located on the main road to Port Albert, which was the main port of entry to the province. Sale was also centrally positioned in Gippsland which made it convenient to the goldfields of Walhalla, Jordan, Boggy Creek and Crooked River (Synan, 1995, p 36).

Powder arrived first into North Gippsland by ship via Port Albert. Later, after the Lakes were opened up to shipping it was delivered to the Latrobe Wharf which was located close to Sale. From here it was transported by horse and wagon straight to the magazine. The powder was stored on 4x4 oregon beams and came in quantities of 25lb, 50lb and 100lb barrels. The turnover of powder in 1871 was 200cwt per month (Synan, 1996). It was illegal for carriers to transport quantities of powder that were in excess of the regulations, those apprehended were summoned to the Sale Police Court. Often a reprimand instead of a fine was given as punishment.

Safety precautions relative to the operation of a powder magazine dominated building design, siting and usage. The Magazine was constructed with massive walls and an arched ceiling that would deflect a blast upwards rather than downwards. The use of wooden pegs in the construction of the floor and fittings eliminated one possible source of sparking. People entering the magazine were required to wear special footwear or none at all.

Bushfires remained a constant threat and although Sale’s Magazine was naturally protected by water it did not remove the threat entirely. Even when a grass fire threatened, the local police sergeant would mount an all night vigil to ensure the safety of the magazine (Synan, 1995, p 36).

With the decline in goldmining in Gippsland there was a reduced demand for the bulk storage of powder, consequently the Office of Mines deemed it necessary to close the magazine in 1881 in the face of local protests. Although the powder magazine no longer served the goldfields the facility remained intact and was put to a military use. In the mid 1880’s militia units were formed to counter act the perceived Russian threat (Synan, 1996). Although the response was exaggerated the Victorian Mounted Rifles was raised and a detachment was based at Sale. They were closely related to the Sale Rifle Club which began operation at around the same time.

Consequently the Borough Council allowed the rifleman to establish a rifle range on the Sale Common which was located not far from the Powder Magazine. These trainee marksman found the magazine a useful facility and used it primarily as an ammunition depot, as did the local detachment of infantrymen, the Victorian Rangers. The magazine was still used by local storekeepers to store small quantities of powder. They supported its retention and paid a small fee for the privilege of using it (Synan, 1995, p 37).

From around 1890 use of the magazine fluctuated as storekeepers and the military did not use it consistently. Other uses were suggested to the Sale Council but nothing eventuated as it was still considered to be a useful asset for the military. In the early 1900’s mining activity in Victoria had waned and the sporadic use of magazines by the military was deemed to be no longer economical. In the case of Sale’s Magazine it was sold to a Thomas Kennedy who took up residence in 1926 (Synan, 1996). It was government policy in Victoria to sell redundant magazines to returned men from WW1 as it was a cheap form of housing (Burill, 1996).

The Magazine was again sold in 1929, to the Garrett family of Longford. During this third stage of occupancy the original building was modified and then extended by the addition of a number of rooms, constructed of weather board and masonite materials. Chimneys, doorways and windows were added as were gardens, trees, creepers and blackberries that have today disguised the original purpose of the building.

In late 1995 interest grew in the Sale Powder Magazine and local government, the Sale Heritage Committee and Historical Society joined forces to begin the purchase, restoration and conservation of a unique building, that had lay hidden very close to town and lost in local history. Since its rediscovery its heritage value has been recognised and it is related directly to Gippsland’s golden decade of the 1860s.

Analysis of the Operating Environment

Magazine Structure

The Sale Powder Magazine is a rectangular red brick structure with a gabled slate roof. There is an entry room located on the western side which is roofed as a continuation of the main roof. The building sits on a course of sandstone blocks and has massive brick walls that were originally buttressed with 10 brick piers. Construction of the ceiling is in the shape of a brick barrel vault, typical of the form adopted for powder magazines. The building has wooden floors one inch thick throughout which are secured by wooden nails. The site is boarded by Stevenson Street and Flooding Creek with the Magazine itself situated at the end of a peninsular, which is formed by a hairpin bend on Flooding Creek.

 

Overall the building is structurally sound but it has undergone some changes. The main modifications are:

  • Of the ten buttresses, six have been removed leaving only one on each corner.
  • All of the wall vents have been sealed, although they still remain and are easily identifiable.
  • A window has been constructed through the western wall to allow additional light.
  • The small north facing window has been replaced by a much larger window. The stone surrounds of the original window have been stored on site.
  • An additional door has been cut through the eastern wall.
  • A double fireplace has been built into the eastern wall, one serving the interior of the building and the other the skillion located on the opposite side.
  • The interior has been partitioned into two rooms. This does not infringe on the integrity of the original building as it is only a temporary structure.
  • The lightning conductors have been removed.
  • The internal brickwork has been painted, as has the exterior of the eastern wall.
  • The storage racks have been removed.
  • Only one post remains of the original fence that acted as a means of controlling entry to the Magazine.
  • The roof is sound although there are some missing and dislodged slates.
  • Original bricks and sandstone bearers are scattered around the property, others have been used to construct the chimneys and fireplaces.

The modifications when viewed in perspective are fairly minor and do not substantially detract from the sense of being in a special building. The vestibule (accounting room) appears to be in its original condition, this includes its windows, doors and locks. All flooring throughout the building is intact and original.

Magazine Site

The Magazine is located 2km from the centre of Sale. Stevenson Street, which is an unsealed but serviceable road is the western boundary of the site. Flooding Creek traverses the peninsula on which the Magazine is located and although the site is subject to flooding, floodwaters have never entered the Magazine or cut access to Stevenson Street. The majority of the rubbish has been cleared and the grass has been slashed, leaving only the Magazine and some old trees on a clear, relatively flat block that gently slopes down to the creek. Town water is connected but power has been disconnected. An external toilet exists and operates on a septic system. There is ample room for the construction of additional buildings that may be required for future development of the site, and the land is zoned accordingly.

Significance in the Built and Social Environment

 

The Sale Powder Magazine is significant in the built and social environment of Sale because: it is a unique example of a Powder Magazine, is of historic importance to the development of Sale as a town and the region of Gippsland and represents considerable social value through its contact with the police, local businessmen and the military links in past and future generations.

Built Environment

Why is the Sale Powder Magazine significant to the built environment ?

  • It is significant as a building because it is one of the few intact and original Powder Magazines extant in Victoria. The basic structure is relatively unchanged and many original fittings are still in situ.
  • It is significant as a powder magazine because the design used to store the black powder has a number of unique features. It sits on a course of sandstone blocks, has four venting points in the ceiling and is protected on three sides by water (Flooding Creek) and on the fourth by a swamp. All these features are found only in the Sale Powder Magazine. The presence of a ‘water barrier’ to protect the Magazine from bushfires is unusual as all other magazines of the same construction had a thick brick wall built around them.
  • It is a significant heritage building as it is one of the oldest remaining structures (circa 1864) in the City of Sale (established in 1844) and is overall in its original condition.

Social Environment

Why was the Sale Powder Magazine significant ?

  • It is significant to the heritage of the Victorian Police Force because from 1864 - 1881 the management of the Magazine was the responsibility of the local police Sergeant. This involvement is significant as it was a part of ordinary police duties in the area of Sale and a number of local police would have worked as Keeper at the Magazine.
  • It is significant to the commerce of the area because local storekeepers could store their powder in the Magazine. Considering the amount of powder that transited through the Magazine (1871 a turnover of 200cwt/month) it would have been a focal point for storekeepers conducting their business and a place that they would have visited regularly.
  • It is significant to the development of the Gippsland region and Sale as the powder was used to mine for gold and many gold miners collected their powder from the Magazine and supplies from local store keepers.
  • It is significant to the development of local militia forces as from 1895 the military used the Magazine as an ammunition store because it was a suitable and safe location. It was located very near the Sale Rifle Range on the Sale Common and would have been a meeting place for the local military detachments of the Victorian Mounted Rifles and Victorian Rangers.
  • The Magazine is significant to Victoria’s military history, as local men belonging to these units, who trained on the rifle range and used the Magazine fought in the Boer War and later in WW1. The Victorian Mounted Rifles in isolation adds additional significance. This unit became the 4th Light Horse Regiment in WW1 which served at Gallipoli and became famous for the Charge of Beersheba in Palestine. Local soldiers from this unit would have been associated with the Sale Powder Magazine as many of those who enlisted in the regiment belonged to local militia units.

ANALYSIS OF THE PROJECT PLAN VALUES

Heritage

The Sale Powder Magazine is an unusual building; in its construction and location. It is the only surviving government powder magazine in Gippsland and was constructed solely to store black powder for use on the Gippsland goldfields. Throughout its history it has had close social ties to the town of Sale and shares with one other building in Sale the distinction of being the oldest structure in town. It is of considerable heritage value to the Wellington Shire and to Victoria as it played an important part in the early history and settlement of the area.

The Powder Magazine is a significant part of the heritage of Sale for its association with gold mining; representing directly this industry which was important in the early development and economic activity of Sale as a township, and of the region. As gold discoveries were made in the Gippsland mountains at Crooked River, Grant, Jordan, Boggy Creek and Walhalla the economy of Sale surged as it developed into a regional centre (Synan, 1996). The lakes and rivers became navigable and Port Albert declined as the main entry point to Gippsland. Sale became the gateway to Gippsland and the Sale Powder Magazine played an important part in expanding the local and regional economy.

Tourism

The Sale powder Magazine is situated on an attractive peninsula bordered by Flooding Creek and is very closely situated to the Wetlands Walk that traverses Lake Guthridge and Lake Guyatt. Both lakes form part of the wetlands that border on the southern edge of Sale township. It is proposed to build a Wetlands Centre at Lake Guthridge which will incorporate a tourist centre and wetland information and education facility (Lush, 1997). With the construction of two bridges to link the Magazine property to Lake Guyatt it could easily be incorporated into the wetlands experience.

The Magazine could be adapted to a small museum featuring goldfields history and artefacts. With the attraction of the Wetlands close by it could be advertised as an adjunct to the wetlands experience. The Magazine is situated on a large block that lends itself to being developed into a park/barbeque area with lawns and nice shade trees. In addition if tourists chose to just visit the Magazine, off street parking is available on the property in an area that is not in the direct line of sight of the building.

At present the prospect of developing a Gippsland Heritage Trail Touring Route is under discussion. The aim is to develop a trail based on Gippsland’s history (Lush, 1997) which would be available for tourists to the area. The Sale Powder Magazine would be an important addition to such a trail as it is an important landmark, representing the gold mining era of Gippsland.

Sale is situated in Gippsland and is on the edge of the Lakes district, consequently many tourists pass through the town enroute to Lakes Entrance and the East coast. Statistics concerning day trips indicate that adults travelling with children are more likely to visit the Gippsland region and stay for an average of 3.9 nights (VRTTS, 1995).

Domestic tourism is steadily rising in Australia and in the year ending June 1996, residents took 63.0 million trips within Australia of at least one nights duration (up 8.9% on y/e June 1995) and spent 256.5 million nights away from home (up 4.1%). In the June Quarter 1996, trips increased by 12.2% and nights by 4.6% compared to the June Quarter 1995, refer Table 1. From these figures it is expected that Gippsland will experience a steady rise in tourist numbers (Tourism Facts, 1996).

The following table demonstrates an increase in domestic tourism in Australia with a steady rise indicated in the number of domestic trips conducted and the number of nights that tourists spent away from home (Tourism Facts, 1996). This information is significant because it demonstrates a continual growth in the tourism industry.

Table 1: DOMESTIC TOURISM

 

Year

Trips (‘000)

Nights (‘000)

 

1990 - 91

48,997

215,448

 

1991 - 92

48,235

216,259

 

1992 - 93

47,878

210,404

 

1993 - 94

48,113

211,373

 

1994 - 95

57,898

246,337

 

1995 - 96

63,028

256,472

 

 

 

The following tables 2 and 3 represents a concise breakdown of visitors to the Gippsland and Lakes regions, illustrating length of stay, purpose of visit, types of activities and expenditure (VRTTS, 1995).

 

The figures in Table 2 (day trips) indicate the following for the Lakes and Gippsland regions (Note: figures added and then averaged, as Sale is in both regions):

 

  • Total day visitors are 1,512,000.

 

  • Total expenditure is 46m.

 

For both regions (the % of) tourists visit on average to:



1. Drive to sightsee/pleasure - 17%

2. Picnic/BBQ - 16% 42% of visitors


3. Organised tour/group activity - 9%

 

This information is significant because it demonstrates that a considerable number of tourists conduct day visits to the region and of these 42% could be potential users of the Magazine site.

 

Table 2: Day Trips

 

Visitors

Lakes

 

Gippsland

Total visitors (‘000)

 

335

1,177

Expenditure ($)

   

Avg. Trip Expenditure

Total Expenditure

35

12m

29

34m

 

Top 10 Activities (% of visitors)

   

Table 3: Overnight Trips

 

Visitors by origin

Lakes

Gippsland

Total visitors (‘000)

Intrastate (%)

Interstate (%)

International (%)

 

894

88

10

2

937

93

6

2

Nights by origin

Total visitors (‘000)

Intrastate (%)

Interstate (%)

International (%)

 

 

3,459

88

8

4

 

2,424

91

7

2

Average stay (nights)

All visitors

 

3.9

 

2.6

 

Purpose of visit (% of visitors)

Holiday

Visiting friends & relatives

Business

Other

 

 

65

21

3

11

 

55

30

3

12

Expenditure ($)

   

Avg. expenditure per night

Avg. expenditure per trip

Total Expenditure

39

150

134m

28

73

69m

 

Top 10 Activities (% of visitors)

   

Visit friends and relatives

Shopping

Drive to sightsee/pleasure

Bushwalking

Restaurants/Dining out

Visit an art gallery/craft centre

Visit a museum/historic site

Visit a National Park/forest

Swimming/diving/surfing

Visit a park or garden

41

47

52

24

46

17

11

21

25

11

49

32

43

31

28

8

9

28

21

6

 

The figures in Table 3 (overnight trips) indicate the following for the Lakes and Gippsland regions, (Note: figures added and then averaged, as Sale is in both regions):

  • The Lakes and Gippsland region both receive a considerable number of tourists each year (1,813,000), as Sale is on the edge of the Lakes those visiting there pass through the town.
  • The majority of visitors are from within Victoria.
  • The average stay for both regions combined is 3.25 days.
  • The majority of tourists visit on holiday.
  • For both regions (the % of) tourists visit on average to:

1. Drive to sightsee/pleasure - 47.5%

2. Visit a museum/historic site - 10%

3. Visit a park/garden - 8.5%

 

  • The combined total expenditure for both regions is 67m.

The combined information from both Table 2 and 3 is significant because it indicates that tourism is of considerable importance to the local economy and that opportunities exist for the Sale Powder Magazine to be incorporated into the local tourism structure. Whilst 10% of visitors visit a museum or historic site the development of the grounds surrounding the Magazine could attract an additional 2% of day visitors and 11% of overnight visitors who visit parklands and gardens.

Education

 

The Sale Powder Magazine, once restored and during its restoration would be of considerable interest to schools in Wellington Shire and possibly further a field. As it is an historic building of considerable local and regional importance its value as an educational tool could be utilised in the following ways:

  • Used for projects on local history and regional history.
  • A focal point for a visit and talk on Australian history.
  • A focal point for history relevant to the Victorian goldrush era.
  • A component of an historical trail that school children could walk or ride bikes around.
  • A research project for the restoration and preservation of an historic building.
  • A history package developed for issue to schools to inform them of the Magazines existence and availability for use by them.
  • A venue for Australian history studies to be taught.

As an educational asset the Magazine is relevant to grades 4 - 6 of primary school and all grades for high school. Table 4 gives an indication of the number of students located in the immediate area of Wellington Shire (DSEV, 1996). It encompasses the former shires of Avon, Maffra, Rosedale and Alberton.

The approximate number of students available to utilise the Magazine site is based on the total number of students attending school minus the number of student (2/5ths of the total) who would be too young to benefit.

The estimate of visitation is based on a school year of 42 weeks duration. It is possible that each grade in both primary and high school would have reason to utilise the Magazine or surrounding grounds or both once a year. By dividing the number of available students by the number of school weeks a figure of 125 students per week is reached. This further reduced by a factor of three as it is more probable that of the students available to visit only a third actually will. Thus it is estimated that 42 students per week could visit the Magazine for a historic visit and or to utilise the surrounding grounds.

The figure of 42 is an estimate as no students may visit some weeks as opposed to other weeks where a large group may visit en masse. This is particularly pertinent to schools that are located some distance from Sale.

Table 4: School Population in the Wellington Shire (immediate vicinity)

 

 

Government Schools

 

Private Schools

Number of schools

 

32

8

Number of students

6,123

 

2,634

     
     
     
 

Total number of students

8,757

 

 
 

Approximate number of students available to use Magazine site

5,255

 

 
 

Estimate of visitation

42 students/week

 

 

 

 

As table 4 demonstrates there is a considerable sustained use available for local schools to utilise the Sale Powder Magazine. In addition the site is also available for use by institutions for further education and the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology has already indicated an interest in being involved in the project. Their exact involvement is yet to be determined but possibilities exist for the Magazine to be utilised as a training aid for architectural students and the subject of various projects. For example, the design and production of information brochures for tourist information centres, production of information packages for schools or expertise provided for the restoration and preservation of the site.

Options for Development

 

Options have been listed so as to generate ideas and promote discussion about potential future uses and management of the Sale Powder Magazine. The intent is not to lay down prescriptive measures for management and use, but to explore possibilities, and the advantages and disadvantages of different options.

Magazine Use Option 1: Heritage building

 

The complete restoration of the Magazine to its original condition. This would include the landscaping of the grounds and the construction of a car park. This would require high initial costs (approximately $56,000) to develop the site. On completion it would be available for group tours and open on designated times to give locals and passing tourists the opportunity to visit the site. Appropriate literature would need to be produced for publicity and distribution to visitors.

To complete restoration of the Magazine the project would proceed in stages taking an estimated thirty one weeks to complete all stages, and would require the necessary funding to complete each stage before the next one was commenced. The stages are as follows:

Stage 1: Repair of Magazine Roof (cost approx. $12,000) (Moylen, 1997)

  • At the northern end of the building the timber barge board is in poor condition and requires replacing to match the original. The north side entry to the porch also requires its barge board to be replaced.
  • The barge board at the southern end of the building requires replacement to match the original (routed lower edges to barge and fascia).
  • Replacement of timber facia on eastern side of building to match original.
  • Replacement of timber facia on western side of building to match original.
  • New ogee profile copper guttering throughout.
  • Reinstate round copper downpipes at each corner of the building and at the northern side of the porch.
  • Retain and repair existing ridge flashing.
  • Remove and replace rotting roof purlins in various locations around building. In particular over main entry door, east side at northern end and ends near fireplace on eastern side.
  • Replace rotted timber roof battens under slate roof to match existing ones.
  • Repair slate roof with slates to match original size (12" x 24"). Approximately 8-10 square metres of slate will need to be replaced.
  • Lichen to be removed from slate roof.
  • Timber eaves and lining boards to be replaced at various locations.
  • Replace rotted concealed roof flashings.

Estimated time for completion 6 weeks

Stage 2: Interior of Magazine (cost approx. $18,000) (Moylen, 1997).

  • Remove brick fireplace and hearth and re-brick wall with salvaged and matching bricks. Replace wooden floor boards in front of hearth if necessary.
  • Remove door on eastern side and re-brick wall with salvaged and matching bricks.
  • Remove double hung window at northern end and re-brick wall with salvaged and matching bricks. Replace small highlight window to match that of southern end (has 2 metal bars and a timber shutter sheathed in copper sheet).
  • Repair crack in wall on northern side.
  • Remove spilt paint from timber floor.
  • Reinstate plain rendered skirting to match existing skirting after the door and fireplace have been removed from the eastern side.
  • Unblock slot wall vents on eastern and western side.
  • Remove double hung window on western side wall and re-brick with salvaged and matching bricks.
  • Replace missing floor boards to match existing boards, fixed with wooden pegs.
  • Repair window in porch by replacing 3 metal bars, re-glaze window, reconstruct and reinstate shutter sheathed in copper sheet to, match original (similar to highlight window at southern end).
  • Remove paint from original doors and service locks.

Estimated time for completion 8 weeks

Stage 3: Exterior of Magazine cost approx. $10,000) (Moylen, 1997).

Northern side of Magazine.

  • Remove brick render from brick wall as necessary.
  • Remove brick render from above stone plinth and re-point stone plinth.
  • Re-point cracks around bearing points of roof purlins.
  • Re-point areas of brickwork and replace mortar to match original.
  • Unblock vent into roof at apex of gable.

Southern side of Magazine.

  • Re-point stone plinth.
  • Reinstate copper sheathed timber shutter (held in storage)
  • Remove paint from brick wall and stone plinth (entrance to porch).
  • Remove light render slurry from wall surface.
  • Unblock vent into roof at apex of gable.

Eastern side of Magazine.

  • Remove remnants of fireplace and rebuild wall using salvaged and matching bricks.
  • Rebuild fronts of existing sandstone plinths to brick buttresses using salvaged and matching sandstone.
  • Rebuild brick buttresses to match original using salvaged and matching bricks.
  • Remove paint from brickwork.
  • Reinstate sub floor vents to match original.
  • Reinstate slot wall vents to match original.
  • Re-point stone plinth.

Western side of Magazine.

  • Rebuild brick buttresses to match original using salvaged and matching bricks.
  • Remove render from existing buttresses.
  • Install new metal grate to match original over existing sub floor vent.
  • Unblock sub floor vents and reinstate to match original.
  • Remove paint from brick wall and stone plinth.
  • Reinstate slot wall vents.
  • Re-point stone plinth.

Estimated time for completion 4 weeks

Stage 4: Fitting out of Interior for Display (cost approx. $9,000).

  • Reconstruct timber shelves for the storage of black powder to match original design and install them at the correct locations in the Magazine (refer original plans).
  • Construct black powder storage barrels in the 3 original sizes used for display purposes.
  • Placement of table and chair in entrance porch for the receiving of visitors.
  • Reconnect power (underground so as to not destroy the natural landscape) and install interior lighting.

Estimated time for completion 5 weeks

Stage 5: Landscaping (cost approx. $3,500).

  • Removal of rubbish.
  • Levelling of the site and fill placed at the end of the peninsula to guard against flooding.
  • Removal of unwanted trees.
  • Planting of new trees and shrubs.
  • Reconstruction of the original fence and gate in front of the Magazine

Estimated time for completion 3 weeks

Stage 6: Car Park (cost approx. $2,500)

  • Levelling of the site.
  • Creation of an entry and exit point.
  • Procurement and fitting of gates.
  • Laying and levelling of gravel.
  • Construct an all weather pathway from the car park to the main track leading to the Magazine.

Estimated time for completion 2 weeks

Stage 7: Promotional Material (cost approx. $1,000)

Production and printing of a brochure for distribution to tourist information centres in Gippsland.

Estimated time for completion 3 weeks

Advantages:

This option is attractive as it ensures that the building and its grounds are restored and preserved for future generations to experience first hand an important component of the Victorian goldrush era. The end result will be an authentically restored powder magazine that reflects the heritage of Sale and its association to the Gippsland goldrush. In attracting visitors to the site to inspect the Magazine some income can be obtained from an admittance fee or group booking fee which would go towards the future upkeep of the site.

Disadvantages:

This option involves a considerable amount of expenditure to ensure the restoration and preservation of the Magazine. It centres around its heritage value only and this could be considered to be a narrow and restrictive view in assessing the potential for its availability of use. This could restrict the application for grants as it would only fit into a very narrow category. To ensure the Magazines continued viability and use, uses other than purely heritage need to be explored. A broader revenue base would also be desirable to ensure the Magazines future as a community asset. Full restoration would involve the refitting of the powder storage racks inside the Magazine and this would severely restrict the use of the internal space. This would make it difficult, without further renovation, to utilise the area for a different purpose.

 

Magazine Use Option 2: Museum

The Magazine’s history is tied to the goldrush era of Victoria and it would be appropriate to use the interior of the Magazine as a small goldfields museum that could include artefacts, photographs and ephemera. To achieve this the Magazine would need to be authentically restored as it itself would be a living reminder of that era. To achieve optimum use of the interior only a sample of the storage racks would be fitted. This would then leave enough room for a museum display and an area suitable for telling the story of the Magazine.

Additional power requirements for the site would be needed and a small toilet block constructed to cater for large groups of visitors. In addition the grounds would need further enhancement to cater for an increased number of visitors. In addition it could be advertised to tourists as many pass through the immediate area (refer table 2 and 3) and also included in the Heritage Trail, a local history trail and included as an adjunct to the Wetlands Centre. Suitable literature for tourists and visitors to the Magazine would need to be produced. A nominal fee could be charged for visiting the site by tourists and organised groups. In the case of group tours it could be a set opening fee. The cost of this option would be approximately $66,200 and take an estimated forty weeks to complete.

To complete option two additional work is required above that listed for option one, with the exception of the installation of all the powder storage racks. The project would proceed in the following stages:

Stage 1: Restoration and Preservation of the site (approx. cost $55,000)

  • Complete stages 1 - 7 as listed under option one.

Estimated time for completion 31 weeks

Stage 2: Conversion of Interior into a Museum (cost approx. $4,700)

  • Power outlets fitted.
  • Installation of security lights and lighting for car park area and approach to Magazine from the car park.
  • Purchase and installation of museum cabinets.
  • Museum displays.
  • Organisation of ticketing and booking system.
  • Installation of telephone.

Estimated time of completion 2 weeks

Stage 3: Enhancement of Grounds (cost approx. $4,500)

  • Provision of 6 park seats in the grounds situated in close proximity to the Magazine.
  • Construction of a toilet block to represent the powder weighing shed, using an authentic design and materials.

Estimated time of completion 3 weeks

Stage 4: Promotional and Educational Material (cost approx. $2,000)

  • Produce additional promotional material for tourists and those visiting the Magazine.

Estimated time of completion 4 weeks

Advantages:

This option has many advantages over option one as it integrates the Magazine more into the local and tourist setting by providing additional uses in the form of a museum and education centre. As the statistics indicate many tourists pass through the town and a considerable number visit a museum or historic site (refer table 3). The inclusion of a museum is an added incentive to attract visitors to the Magazine and in doing so increases its ability to collect additional finances that ultimately will ensure its continued viability. It provides additional opportunities for applying for grants and on completion of the project its value as a community asset is enhanced.

Disadvantages:

To achieve this option a considerable amount of additional money is required apart from that identified in option one. This could mean a long and protracted effort to acquire the funds needed. It also means that progress will be hampered by the availability of funds to complete the work.

Magazine Use

Option 3: Heritage Building, Museum, Education Centre and Parkland

This option encompasses uses highlighted in option one and two but with an additional focus on community use in relation to education and its location. Apart from being a heritage building on display and goldfields museum it could also be an education centre and recreation parkland. The Magazine could be made available to schools for educational purposes and used by them for projects, history lessons and tours. Statistics show that a continued use by schools in the area is quite probable (refer table 4).

The opportunity exists to raise the profile and community use of the Magazine by enhancing its surrounding grounds into parkland. This can be achieved by constructing two bridges over Flooding Creek with an entry and exit bridge linked to the walking track around Lake Guyatt, which is part of the Wetlands trail. It can not only be advertised as an historic site but also as an adjunct to the Wetlands walk. With the site landscaped and additional suitable shade trees planted the site could be transformed into a very attractive and peaceful picnic/BBQ area. Some revenue could be raised by the use of electric BBQ’s.

The appearance of Flooding Creek could be enhanced by the digging of a number of holes along its northern side. This would provide more water retention around the site and eventually, due to the depth of the holes a lot of the weed would disappear. With the increase in the expanse of water in the creek bird life would become more prolific. This would enhance the aesthetics of the site overall. In conjunction with the uses mentioned the development of the grounds into parkland could attract a considerable number additional visitors (refer table 2 and 3), both tourists and locals.

This aspect is important because if the Wellington Shire can see a direct asset to the whole community by the addition of another park in Sale it is possible that they will support the upkeep of the grounds. A park setting will attract locals and tourists to the area and raise the profile of the Magazine. The grounds can also become a focal point for community ceremonies eg Australia Day. A flag pole can be erected permanently for this purpose. Apart from schools, tourists and locals visiting the Magazine it could be made available as a meeting place for local historical and youth groups as an occasional alternative meeting place.

Revenue could be collected from museum entry, an opening fee for large groups of tourists, a nominal fee for hire as a meeting place and the hire of the grounds for special private events eg wedding photography or a fundraising activity. This option makes use of all the Sale Powder Magazines assets, both building and grounds.

To complete this option additional work is required apart from that listed in option one and two. The cost of this option would be approximately $80,550 and take an estimated forty eight weeks to complete. The project would proceed in the following stages:

Stage 1: Restoration and Preservation of the site (cost approx. $55,000)

  • Complete stages 1 - 7 as listed under option one.

Estimated time of completion 31 weeks

nversion into a Museum
(cost approx. $11,200)

  • Complete stages 2 - 4 as listed under option two.

Estimated time of completion 9 weeks

Stage 3: Parkland (cost approx. $11,850)

Construct two bridges over Flooding Creek.

Plant additional shade trees.

Install ten park seats and eight picnic tables with seats.

Install eight electric BBQ’s.

Install one flag pole with Australian National flag.

Estimated time of completion 4 weeks

Stage 4: Enhancement of Flooding Creek (cost approx. $1,000)

Dig three deep holes in the northern side of Flooding Creek.

Remove the old fence in the creek.

Poison blackberry bushes along each side of Flooding Creek.

Estimated time of completion 1 week

Stage 5: Educational Material (cost approx. $1,500)

Produce educational training packages for schools.

Estimated time of completion 3 weeks

Advantages:

This option achieves all the goals listed for the project and combines the best assets of the Magazine and its surrounding grounds to develops them into a very diversified and valuable community asset. In doing so it ensures that a valuable heritage building is restored and preserved and that its continued viability is ensured by projecting what it has to offer to the broader local community and visitors.

The Magazine will provide an authentic link for the region to the Gippsland goldrush and the inclusion of a museum further enhances its importance as an historic landmark. The transformation of the grounds into beautiful parkland would create a very useful and unique community asset. Sale does not have such a park located in town nor does it have an area suitable for important community events. This is the ideal place as it is attractive, has one of the oldest existing buildings in town and is very close to the town centre.

By diversifying the available uses of the Magazine site it provides a wider revenue base to support the operations of the site which in turn ensures its economic and future viability. The project, although large is flexible as it can be approached in stages and does not necessarily have to proceed in the order given.

Disadvantages:

To achieve the desired outcomes to this option it will take forty eight weeks to complete and require substantial funds. It is unlikely that all the funding would be secured at the one time to ensure the projects stages are comleted one directly after the other. This will mean that the project may take some years to complete and is totally reliant on obtaining funds, as only a small amount can be achieved by local community groups in relation to restoring the Magazine. If the project takes too long to complete there is a risk that local support and interest may wain which could again further delay completion.

POTENTIAL SOURCES OF FUNDING

In attracting funding for the project a sponsor can contribute to a stage of one of the options or if they desire to the overall project. Sponsorship can be in the form of a direct donation of funds, materials, labour, plant machinery and operation, consultancy services, publication of advertising, tourism and educational materials or a direct grant.

Local Organisations that Support Community Projects.

  • Rotary.
  • Lions.
  • Apex.
  • Masonic Lodges.

Corporate Organisations that Support Heritage and Community Projects.

  • Esso.
  • Fulham Prison.
  • Eastern Energy.
  • ICI.

Local and State Departments that Support Heritage Projects.

  • Wellington Shire Council Community Grants Program.
  • Department of Premier and Cabinet Community Support Fund, accessed through Wellington Shire Council.
  • Minister for Conservation and the Environment Conservation Project Grant.
  • Parks Victoria.
  • Department of Sports and Recreation.

PREFERRED OPTION

The preferred option is option three because it takes an holistic approach to achieving the goals of the project. Unfortunately today the fact that the Magazine is a heritage building is not enough in itself to ensure its continued preservation or viability. Option three provides a diversified economic structure to draw in revenue which will help to ensure the Sale Powder Magazines continued preservation and future use.

Option three offers a diversity of uses not included in options one and two. Although it will take more funds and a much longer time frame to complete the result will be an excellent community asset. It will provide the following assets to Sale, all of which there is no present equivalent.

Restored heritage building: Sale does not have any authentically restored buildings from the early part of its settlement. The powder Magazine provides a link to the early commerce of the district, the goldrush era, the local police force and Australias early military history. No other building in Sale provides such a diversity of heritage.

Goldfields Museum: The history of the Gippsland goldrush and the contribution of Sale to it is not represented anywhere else in the district. This segment of history has been largely forgotten and the conversion of the Magazine into a museum depicting that era would redress this deficiency. The Magazine is the ideal location for such a display as the building was constructed as a direct result of the goldrush and is one of only a few buildings in Gippsland that provides evidence of that era.

Education Centre: The Magazine offers a unique setting for school children to learn about the early settlement of the area and the Gippsland goldrush. Local schools have indicated an interest in using the site. Apart from the local museum there are no other heritage buildings that have been restored or available for educational purposes. The Magazine was built to perform a specific task, that of storing black powder and is the only specially designed building in town that can be restored to educate all ages about an important phase of development in Sale and district. Apart from schools the building is of interest to students from terterary institutions to study its design and purpose. The Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology has expressed an interest in the Magazine.

Parkland: Sale does not have many picturesk parkland areas suitable for a quiet picnic or small community events. The grounds of the Magazine can be converted at a small cost, and predominately by volunteer labour into a beautiful parkland area. With bridges established between the site and Lake Gyatt the Magazine will become incorporated into the Wetlands Walk adding an interesting adjunct for visitors to the Wetlands. A restored Magazine surrounded by a vista of water from Flooding Creek and beautiful parkland will provide the ideal setting for important local and national events, for example Australia Day. Sale has no other such place that can embody all the aspects of the towns early history and provide a unique setting for education, recreation and a focal point for future historical gatherings.

Option three, apart from providing a community asset will also be of interest to tourisits visiting the area. With the correct publicity and incorporation into the local tourist industry it has the potential to develop into a prominent local landmark that will be associated with Sale and included with other points of interest for visitors to view. The resultant benefits that the Magazine can provide to the town justify the cost of restoration, preservation and development. It is not in direct competition with any other projects as no other can provide the diversification of uses that the Sale Powder Magazine can to its local residents, nieghbours or visitors.

REFERENCES

Burill, R. (1996). Expert on Powder Magazines in Victoria: Bendigo.

Department of Industry, Science and Tourism, (1996). Tourism Facts: Canberra.

Directorate of School Education Victoria. (1996).

Lush, A. (1997). Tourism Officer Wellington Shire Council: Sale.

Moylen, G. (1997). Sale Powder Magazine Schedule of Works: Wellington Shire Council: Sale.

Synan, P. (1995). The Rediscovery of the Sale Powder Magazine: Gippsland Heritage Journal No. 18.

Synan, P. (1996). Sale Town Historian: Sale.

Victorian Regional Travel and Tourism Survey, (1995). Tourism Facts Issued August 1996: Melbourne.

Researched and Prepared by Wayne Bell

Members Bulletin Projects Students Links GuestBook History